Getting into any investment without any exit strategy can be fatal. Some people I know in my workplace put money into something just because it is a “good buy”. However, buying things doesn’t make you money, does it? It’s selling them that does.As a simple case in point, my colleague bought a penny stock through recommendation at a pretty good price and it was doing fairly well, appreciating a few cents for the following few days and mind you, a few cents in penny stocks is huge.
She bought almost 50 lots at 0.105 and it peaked at 0.15 and hovered around 0.12 to 0.13 for at least the following 2-3 weeks. That’s 15 - 20% profit! Yet, she insisted on holding it, claiming that it can increase more. Greed, in other words, gets in the way.
And the following month saw the decrease to 0.11 and hovering at that for a good one month or so before plunging below her buying price. Even at 0.11 was a 5% which, and after all the fees, translates to couple of hundreds bucks, not too bad if you ask me.
She insisted on keeping even after paper loss of 10% and it has been 3 months where the price hovers around 0.095 to 0.1, in which I suggest cutting losses. As of now, the price is standing at 0.09 with a paper loss of 700+ bucks; good luck to that.
She probably didn’t know what she was getting into; she had no idea what that company was, what kind of business they are doing, etc., basically basing her buy on hearsay. Even worse was that there wasn’t even the slightest idea of how, what and when she can expect to get out of that speculation. Of course, she is also dangerously putting all eggs in one basket, but well, that’s a topic for another day.
Exit strategy in this context basically refers to the taking of profits or cutting losses when they rise or fall to a certain percentage. This can be done by oneself or done through take-profit or stop-loss orders with your broker to automate the process.
For speculation, traders typically use technical analysis to determine the optimal exit point for maximizing profits or eliminate holdings that don’t perform. On the other hand and personally, people who play for long term, like for example indexing, set specific targets within certain period of time-frame to lock in the profits to either reduce trading frequencies, reduce downside potential for capital preservation or rebalancing purposes. In short, all these strategies help by removing the emotion factor from the equation to reduce risk.
It’s also like buying a car, where despite the fact that it depreciates, what exit strategy do you have in mind and how much you are willing to lose are important considerations that needs to be made prior to buying in. One way to help make that decision is perhaps through calculation of the breakeven point of your car loan and car value?
This can also be said the same for your career as well and now your time is the investment in question. Are you still learning new things and contributing to your professional growth? Are you heading in the direction you want in your career? Do you see any prospects in your company or department? These are some of the considerations that are worth thinking about when making your investment of your most important resource.
On the point of career, not everyone is willing to work past 65, just as some are not comfortable in retiring too young at say 45. Having a clear exit strategy will ultimately define your retirement planning; how aggressive you need to save, how much risk you can take, etc.
Great article. Two questions: 1) What is your personal exit strategy for investments? 2) What is the breakeven point of a car loan and car value and how does that factor in making a car purchase?
ReplyDeleteCar loan and car value got breakeven point ah? haha...
ReplyDelete1) Personal exit strategy is to set aside a certain target at which I want or depends on market sentiment. In the last correction, I decided to let off some units of my mutual fund, even though I have not reached my target, so as to re-enter at a lower price. Although the gain wasn’t really significant, it’s about putting what I learnt in practice, haha.
ReplyDelete2) Hmmm, its the point at which the paper value of the car crosses the amount you owe the bank due to the car loan, at which you can fetch a positive amount when you trade in your car. Am I right to say this ah? I supposed this then will let you decide whether you are ok with financing for that amount of time?
I am uncomfortable with a few points on 1). One, I suppose you're a speculator. So you would base your exit strategy on technical analysis for optimal exit point. Question: is market sentiment suppose to factor in this "technical" analysis? Two, how did you arrive at the "soft target" for your mutual fund investment? If it is based on "technical analysis" then you have derived your optimal exit point in which case you should not waiver from that position, otherwise no matter how rational you think you are, you have injected emotions into your investment strategy. If, however, you had miscalculated your optimal exit point, then the most important thing is to examine what was missing in your technical analysis, so as to calibrate your optimal exit point.
ReplyDeleteOn 2), agree with Jere there isnt a breakeven point. It simply means you are repaying too much for a given duration of time :p
break even pt is what they mention more in insurance rite? when amt u can punch out in cash(when cancelling) is equal to the amt u put in after a certain number of years. The car is an always depreciating asset( as opposed to ur insurance which increases with time), so technically u nvr break 'even', even when that happens. cos u lose ur amt u paid until that pt.
ReplyDeleteI wan to retire at 45 le. where got too early. if 35 can retire i retire lor. just tt too poor to.
ReplyDeleteAnyways can i ask why u prefer investing in mutual funds?
No jere, I dun prefer mutual funds. I’m merely using it as a vehicle to accumulate wealth, using its RSP (Regular Savings Plan) option, for indexing in the future. BK, I would then think that a more appropriate exit point for this should be when I accumulated the target amount. But, I thought that’s pretty passive, which is why I set aside a secondary target price at which to lock in profit and rebalance with a money market fund. How I arrive at that target price is no technical analysis, it’s by target percentage gain.
ReplyDeleteCan la jere, to retire at 45, but means you have to plan it properly like now, so that you understand what to expect for your retirement in order to lead a reasonable life right? Else, that ain’t retiring, that’s suicide. That’s the exit strategy I meant…
As for 2) I guess you guys are right... shouldn’t have applied the insurance concept here...
I dun understand what you mean by indexing and primary/secondary target amount, target percentage gain, etc... Next time we meet explain to me plssss
ReplyDelete